Kill Switch vs. IGLA:
Which Actually Stops Theft?
Kill switches have been around for decades. But modern thieves have evolved. Here's an honest comparison of traditional kill switches versus digital immobilizers like IGLA.
Quick Answer
Traditional kill switches can be found and bypassed in minutes. IGLA is invisible and requires a secret PIN sequence that thieves can't discover or bypass. For modern keyless vehicles, IGLA is significantly more effective.
What Is a Kill Switch?
A kill switch is a hidden switch that interrupts the electrical circuit needed to start your car. When activated, the car won't start—even with the correct key. Common types include:
- Fuel pump kill switch: Cuts power to the fuel pump
- Ignition kill switch: Interrupts the ignition circuit
- Starter kill switch: Prevents the starter motor from engaging
- Battery disconnect: Kills power entirely
Kill switches are typically installed in hidden locations—under the dash, behind a panel, or near the seat. The idea is that a thief won't know where to look.
Why Kill Switches Worked (Past Tense)
Kill switches were effective when car theft meant hot-wiring. A thief would break in, connect some wires under the steering column, and drive away. If a kill switch interrupted that circuit, the car wouldn't start.
This worked because:
- Thieves had limited time and tools
- Each car had different wiring
- Finding the switch required physical searching
- Most thieves were opportunistic, not organized
Why Kill Switches Fail Against Modern Thieves
Kill Switches Are Findable
Professional thieves know the common hiding spots. Under the dash, behind the kick panel, near the OBD port—they've seen it all. A kill switch can typically be found and bypassed in 3-5 minutes.
Relay Attacks Bypass Everything
A kill switch doesn't protect against relay attacks. If thieves relay your key fob signal, the car thinks it has a valid key. The kill switch won't activate because the car was "legitimately" unlocked and started.
Physical Wires Can Be Jumped
Kill switches use physical wire interruption. A thief with basic electrical knowledge can jumper across the switch or simply splice the wires together. It's not sophisticated—it's just wire.
Valet/Family Members
Kill switches require you to show someone where it is. Your valet, mechanic, or family member now knows your security secret. One slip and your protection is compromised.
How IGLA Is Different
IGLA is a digital immobilizer that works through the car's existing CAN bus network. Instead of interrupting a physical wire, it monitors and controls engine authorization at the software level.
Completely Invisible
No switch to find. The module is hidden and soldered into the wiring harness. Even knowing it's there, locating and removing it takes hours.
PIN-Based Authorization
You enter a secret code using existing buttons. No key, no switch, no visible action. Thieves can't watch and learn it.
Stops Relay Attacks
Even if thieves relay your key signal and unlock the car, it won't drive without your PIN. This is the key difference for keyless vehicles.
Can't Be Jumped
There's no wire to bypass. IGLA controls engine authorization through encrypted CAN bus communication. You can't "jumper" around software.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Kill Switch | IGLA |
|---|---|---|
| Stops relay attacks | No | Yes |
| Invisible to thieves | No | Yes |
| Can be bypassed | 3-5 min | Hours+ |
| Valet mode | Show location | Temporary disable |
| OBD port protection | None | Yes |
| Typical cost | $150-400 | $1,200-1,800 |
| Works on modern keyless cars | Partial | Yes |
When a Kill Switch Still Makes Sense
Kill switches aren't useless—they're just not the right solution for modern keyless vehicles. A kill switch can still work for:
- Older vehicles without keyless entry: Pre-2010 cars that require physical key insertion
- Budget protection: When $1,500 isn't feasible, a $200 kill switch is better than nothing
- Layered security: As an additional deterrent alongside other measures
- Classic cars: Vehicles where modern CAN bus solutions don't apply
But if you're driving a modern keyless vehicle—especially a high-theft target—a kill switch alone won't protect you from the methods thieves actually use.
The Bottom Line
Kill switches were designed for a different era of car theft. Relay attacks, CAN bus injection, and key cloning have made them largely obsolete for modern vehicles. If you're protecting a keyless car worth $40,000+, the $1,000 price difference between a kill switch and IGLA is negligible compared to the protection gap.
Check IGLA Availability